Karyn Maughan demystifies the NPA’s extradition ruling headache

Loading player...
The way South Africa’s prosecutors go about extraditing the criminally accused from another country to face justice in a local court is currently under intense scrutiny. The crux of the matter is that in 2014, the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) ruled in one particular case that only the country’s Justice Minister and not the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) is allowed to make extradition requests. This effectively allowed the former personal assistant to ex-Free State Premier Ace Magashule, Moroadi Cholota, to argue her way to walking free in the so-called asbestos tender trial. And now the SCA ruling may affect nearly ninety other extradition matters, including the murder case of rapper Kiernan “AKA” Forbes and Tebello “Tibz” Motsoane. Our resident legal journalist, Karyn Maughan, joins us in this edition of The Lead to help us demystify this major legal precedent. Later in the show, host Graeme Raubenheimer takes us to Midrand where former EFF turned MKP politician Floyd Shivambu says he’s consulting the possibility of starting a new party but won’t resign from the MKP. Finally, Kyalami race track solidifies plans to jumpstart to Formula One status. You can now send a short voice note of 15 to 20 seconds with your questions or thoughts on this episode to our official The Lead WhatsApp line, that’s: +27 72 562 3179. Mail your comments to thelead@24.com. Editions drop Monday through Thursday at 19:00 on Spotify, Apple and YouTube.
Chapters
  • 00:01 Graeme's intro
  • 02:16 Interview with Karyn Maughan
  • 29:10 Trending topic: Shivambu's presser
  • 31:20 AD: The Weekender
  • 31:47 And finally: Kyalami gears up for F1
  • 35:14 Your voicenotes!
19 Jun English South Africa News · Society & Culture

Other recent episodes

Pierre de Vos judges the judiciary in 2025. PLUS, KZN legislature chaos 

Have you clocked out for the year already? On the beach yet? Switched off? Well, constitutional law expert Pierre de Vos has, but not before giving us his last interview for the year. Touching on all his highs and lows for the judiciary in 2025, from one judge allegedly receiving church…
15 Dec 27 min

Can the black middle class save the ANC from collapse? 

The ANC is introspecting. If its National General Council is anything to go by, the continent’s oldest liberation party appears to be serious about reversing its sliding scale of victory. But the yellow and green giant forged in the images of Luthuli, Sisulu and Mandela cannot rebuild without the full…
11 Dec 37 min

Inside the ANC’s soul-searching NGC – vote buying, step-asides and succession

An end to vote-buying at elective conferences. And a stricter step-aside ruling for those accused of corruption. These are just some of the party policy changes the African National Congress (ANC) is mulling over at its current National General Council in Boksburg. As our political reporter, Soyiso Maliti debuts on…
10 Dec 18 min

ANC and DA succession races – Didiza rising, Hill-Lewis waiting?

The DA won’t be led by John Steenhuisen forever, and this is President Cyril Ramaphosa’s final turn at the helm of Africa’s oldest liberation movement, the ANC. While most of us have our minds on the beach at this time of year, News24 editor-in-chief Adriaan Basson has some very informed…
9 Dec 22 min

‘Vlam’ extinguished - why was crimefighter Marius van der Merwe killed?

Nicknamed “vlam”, or flame in English, 41-year-old Brakpan crimefighter Marius van der Merwe was shot and killed last Friday at his home. It’s mere weeks after he, as Witness D at the Madlanga Commission, detailed an alleged 2022 murder cover-up involving deputy Ekurhuleni top metro cop, Julius Mkhwanazi. And it…
8 Dec 19 min